PORTAL Art&Business | PORTAL WOMANCOMM | KREATIVNI PORTFOLIO 03 | HOTEL JUGOSLAVIJA (PDF)
Media-Marketing.com
  • News

    Seven ambassadors, seven photogrephers, one story. The elegance of the collective.

    Novak Djokovic and Raiffeisen Bank International sign partnership

    No Joke The Deadline Extension Is April 30.

    Elan’s folding ski best wins in category with ground-breaking design

    Rok za prijavo del je podaljšan

    MediaCom Is Impossible Foods’ New Media Agency Partner

  • Weekly topic
    daljinski-naslovnica

    Television Audience Measurement: In Serbia, the media are in a race to the bottom for every extra “click”, while in Croatia HTV has undermined the principle of joint monitoring

    This global pandemic, coronavirus, cuts across all geographical borders regardless of cultures and language. What is the role of Public relations today?

    Slaven Fischer: Creativity doesn’t reside in buildings but in people, no matter where they are. It’s natural for people to work from home.

    Janja Božič Marolt: As in every crisis, there will be a lot of victims and some winners in the communications industry of the region.

    Shortcutting Video: New Study Highlights the Effectiveness of 2-second Ads

    Topic of the Day: Can artificial intelligence replace human intelligence and emotions. Is technology a servant or a master?

  • Interview
    Scott-Gould-naslovnica

    Scot Gould: Stop doing anything that you do that isn’t valuable, tell everyone about that offering, and don’t stop!

    lazar-naslovnica

    Lazar Džamić: We are experts at preferring the byways, swamps, and chasms, so that we can keep on going in circles, lost in space

    Irena-naslovna

    Irena Kurtanjek: Contributing to the Communities in which we Operate is the Foundation of Nestlé’s Business

    Ogilvy Social.Lab NASLOVNA

    Exclusive: Media Marketing declares Diego Maradona tribute – the video of the year! This is the interview with the team who made everything happen in only five days!

    intervju-naslovnicaa

    Aleksandra Dilevska: The CORONA Crisis has forced us to show our true mettle and take a leap into the future

    steven-farell-naslovnica-nova

    Stephen Farrell: The influencer industry is over saturated and lacks diversity

  • Opinion
    misa-naslovnica

    Miša Lukić: What can start-ups learn from sperm?

    Do Brands Always Need to Sell Aggressively to Grow?

    Price of Hate

    The Advertising Industry: From Alchemists to Distributors and Back Again

    Milena Garfield: It’s not long since I said: If it ain’t live, it’s dead

    Pripravljeni na vse, kar sledi

  • Diary

    Diary of a Methuselah #176 Will our industry come out of this better and smarter?

    Diary of a Methuselah #159: Ivo Pogorelić and Zoran Todorović weren’t attractive enough for sponsors in Sarajevo

    Diary of a Methuselah #157: The Young Leaders of Tomorrow, a great event for young people who are ready to assume responsibility for the future of industry

    Diary of a Methuselah #156: I’ve been writing my Diary for three years now, and I don’t think I wrote anything smart

    Diary of a Methuselah #154: Three days at the PRO.PR Conference

    Diary of a Methuselah #153: Portal Media Marketing starts a new life today

  • Young Leaders

    Mladi liderji – Uroš Zorčič, New Moment Ljubljana: Vedno gledam na dela sama in ne postavljam v ospredje posameznih ljudi ali agencij

    Mladi liderji – Saša Droftina, Luna \TBWA: Želela bi, da bi se spremenil odnos do pitchev

    Mladi Lideri Kristina Gregorc

    Mladi liderji – Kristina Gregorc, Mercator: Zelo sem optimistična in izjemno ponosna in vesela, da sem del tako velike in uspešne ekipe

    Mladi Lideri

    Mladi liderji – Maša Crnkovič, Futura DDB: Največji izziv je vpeljava podatkov in feedback-a uporabnikov v procese dela

    Young leaders – Aneta Nedimović, New Moment Belgrade: Articulating ideas and the value of those ideas is an art form and a skill

    Mladi liderji – Matjaž Muhič, ArnoldVuga: Želel bi več časa za razmislek, za delo, za raziskovanje

  • 3 questions

    Robert Wester: Strategic communications is at the top of the European Commission’s agenda

    Chris Pomeroy: Tourism in 2019 accounted for 1 in 10 jobs on the planet and until now it was resilient to all manner of crisis

    Andrey Barannikov: The role of PR in Russia is changing and becoming more strategically important both for brands and communication agencies

    francis-ingram-naslovnica

    Three questions for Francis Ingham, Managing Director of the Public Relations and Communications Association (PRCA) & Chief Executive of the International Communications Consultancy Organization (ICCO)

    3 questions for Svetlana Stavreva, President of the International PR association (IPRA): Today, people are demanding that organizations do what they promised

    Three questions for Petra Krulc, Senior Vice President of Celtra

  • WOMANCOMM
    nastja-naslovna-2-min

    Nastja Mulej: The time has come for women to show what they’ve got!

    Maja Kolarić: One of the beauties of art is how it can imbue a city with global spirit

    7 Notable Women in Advertising

  • B/H/S
No Result
View All Result
Media-Marketing.com
  • News

    Seven ambassadors, seven photogrephers, one story. The elegance of the collective.

    Novak Djokovic and Raiffeisen Bank International sign partnership

    No Joke The Deadline Extension Is April 30.

    Elan’s folding ski best wins in category with ground-breaking design

    Rok za prijavo del je podaljšan

    MediaCom Is Impossible Foods’ New Media Agency Partner

  • Weekly topic
    daljinski-naslovnica

    Television Audience Measurement: In Serbia, the media are in a race to the bottom for every extra “click”, while in Croatia HTV has undermined the principle of joint monitoring

    This global pandemic, coronavirus, cuts across all geographical borders regardless of cultures and language. What is the role of Public relations today?

    Slaven Fischer: Creativity doesn’t reside in buildings but in people, no matter where they are. It’s natural for people to work from home.

    Janja Božič Marolt: As in every crisis, there will be a lot of victims and some winners in the communications industry of the region.

    Shortcutting Video: New Study Highlights the Effectiveness of 2-second Ads

    Topic of the Day: Can artificial intelligence replace human intelligence and emotions. Is technology a servant or a master?

  • Interview
    Scott-Gould-naslovnica

    Scot Gould: Stop doing anything that you do that isn’t valuable, tell everyone about that offering, and don’t stop!

    lazar-naslovnica

    Lazar Džamić: We are experts at preferring the byways, swamps, and chasms, so that we can keep on going in circles, lost in space

    Irena-naslovna

    Irena Kurtanjek: Contributing to the Communities in which we Operate is the Foundation of Nestlé’s Business

    Ogilvy Social.Lab NASLOVNA

    Exclusive: Media Marketing declares Diego Maradona tribute – the video of the year! This is the interview with the team who made everything happen in only five days!

    intervju-naslovnicaa

    Aleksandra Dilevska: The CORONA Crisis has forced us to show our true mettle and take a leap into the future

    steven-farell-naslovnica-nova

    Stephen Farrell: The influencer industry is over saturated and lacks diversity

  • Opinion
    misa-naslovnica

    Miša Lukić: What can start-ups learn from sperm?

    Do Brands Always Need to Sell Aggressively to Grow?

    Price of Hate

    The Advertising Industry: From Alchemists to Distributors and Back Again

    Milena Garfield: It’s not long since I said: If it ain’t live, it’s dead

    Pripravljeni na vse, kar sledi

  • Diary

    Diary of a Methuselah #176 Will our industry come out of this better and smarter?

    Diary of a Methuselah #159: Ivo Pogorelić and Zoran Todorović weren’t attractive enough for sponsors in Sarajevo

    Diary of a Methuselah #157: The Young Leaders of Tomorrow, a great event for young people who are ready to assume responsibility for the future of industry

    Diary of a Methuselah #156: I’ve been writing my Diary for three years now, and I don’t think I wrote anything smart

    Diary of a Methuselah #154: Three days at the PRO.PR Conference

    Diary of a Methuselah #153: Portal Media Marketing starts a new life today

  • Young Leaders

    Mladi liderji – Uroš Zorčič, New Moment Ljubljana: Vedno gledam na dela sama in ne postavljam v ospredje posameznih ljudi ali agencij

    Mladi liderji – Saša Droftina, Luna \TBWA: Želela bi, da bi se spremenil odnos do pitchev

    Mladi Lideri Kristina Gregorc

    Mladi liderji – Kristina Gregorc, Mercator: Zelo sem optimistična in izjemno ponosna in vesela, da sem del tako velike in uspešne ekipe

    Mladi Lideri

    Mladi liderji – Maša Crnkovič, Futura DDB: Največji izziv je vpeljava podatkov in feedback-a uporabnikov v procese dela

    Young leaders – Aneta Nedimović, New Moment Belgrade: Articulating ideas and the value of those ideas is an art form and a skill

    Mladi liderji – Matjaž Muhič, ArnoldVuga: Želel bi več časa za razmislek, za delo, za raziskovanje

  • 3 questions

    Robert Wester: Strategic communications is at the top of the European Commission’s agenda

    Chris Pomeroy: Tourism in 2019 accounted for 1 in 10 jobs on the planet and until now it was resilient to all manner of crisis

    Andrey Barannikov: The role of PR in Russia is changing and becoming more strategically important both for brands and communication agencies

    francis-ingram-naslovnica

    Three questions for Francis Ingham, Managing Director of the Public Relations and Communications Association (PRCA) & Chief Executive of the International Communications Consultancy Organization (ICCO)

    3 questions for Svetlana Stavreva, President of the International PR association (IPRA): Today, people are demanding that organizations do what they promised

    Three questions for Petra Krulc, Senior Vice President of Celtra

  • WOMANCOMM
    nastja-naslovna-2-min

    Nastja Mulej: The time has come for women to show what they’ve got!

    Maja Kolarić: One of the beauties of art is how it can imbue a city with global spirit

    7 Notable Women in Advertising

  • B/H/S
No Result
View All Result
Media-Marketing.com
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Three theories about how commercials work

We have this responsibility to lower the threshold for nonsense. And to maintain a high level of comprehensive knowledge on the whole time

02/07/2018
in Opinion
4 min read
Three theories about how commercials work

Drugi jezik na kojem je dostupan ovaj članak: Bosnian

By: Johan Östlund, Group CEO, McCann Sweden

Source: Resumé, Sweden

“It is just a theory, so it doesn’t really work in practice“. How many times has one heard something like that? This quote has always astounded me.

The truth is that there is actually nothing more practical than a good theory.

When people work in a practical way on anything related to macroeconomics and consumer goods marketing, all points of view and recommendations tend to create some sort of theory. It is inevitable.

The problem is that many people cannot really tell which theory or knowledge platform they base their recommendations on (it is perhaps observed as common sense?). Or they know which theory they take as their starting point, but at the same time they don’t realize that it may be insufficiently corroborated and thus unsuitable to be an appropriate base. Or they don’t know that there are two opposed theories which both have their strengths and weaknesses and that one should be familiar with both.

A good theory is a corroborated one. One that has been tested time and time again. Always challenged, developed, challenged and developed all over again etc. Always by thorough methods and through practical experience which thereby gets incorporated to provide a better knowledge platform. A sharp contrast to an appealingly and modernly wrapped nonsense, in other words – without substance.

My ambition with this column is to raise awareness on this contemporary phenomenon because I feel that appealingly and modernly wrapped nonsense seems to get more and more space. The amusing provocateur Bob Hoffman speaks about it, among other things, in a very stimulative manner (even though in essence it is depressing since we are knee-deep in nonsense) in his performance called The Golden Age of Bullshit:

In our field, we have this responsibility to lower the threshold for nonsense. And to maintain a high level of comprehensive knowledge on the whole time.

An event that has reshaped me for good happened almost exactly 18 years ago: randomly browsing (I was trying to find any possible excuse not to study, something which I of course had to do) through an issue of International Journal of Advertising from 1999, I came across an article called “The Emperor’s old clothes: a rejoinder” by Andrew Ehrenberg.

I remember that I was reading his rebuttal of an article written before by Roderick White called “What can advertising really do for brands” and had to put it away. What he said tickled and moved me greatly. I’ve never heard of that guy, Andrew Ehrenberg (everyone who today refers to Byron Sharp and his “How Brands Grow” hopefully knows that Sharp’s research is based on the work of the nowadays abandoned Ehrenberg). Ehrenberg led a convincing scientific discussion supporting a theory that a commercial doesn’t work in the way that the AIDA-model (Attention Interest Desire Action) claims.

What?

I believed, in my foolishness, that the AIDA-model wasn’t a theory but the truth. And suddenly it was thoroughly challenged. I felt as if I was losing the ground beneath my feet. It took a while before I dared to open that journal again and above all open up to the idea that what I believed was true maybe wasn’t.

What I stumbled upon was a debate which had been making its rounds in academic circles for a long time, aiming at establishing which explanatory model about how commercials work should prevail. The area is extremely important for practitioners since the dominant model dictates all – from the production to the evaluation of a commercial.

And so, 18 years later, I can conclude that many marketers are on the one hand unblissfully ignorant that there is a debate on explanatory models at all, and on the other – many still work relying on the AIDA-model as a base, since that is the only one they know. However, this type of hierarchical decision-making models (there are several with different names, but they all rely on the same assumption about how people process information sequentially following predetermined and identifiable steps) developed more than a hundred years ago. These models were partly built on assumptions and partly on bases which do not necessarily correspond with how people actually make decisions – relying on what we know today about people and their decision-making processes.

What we can conclude instead is that there are three theories (which, I dare claim are complementary) about how commercials work – stating that anyone who comes into contact with commercial content has to have some knowledge about it – which is best explained in the brilliant article “Persuasion, pride and prejudice: how ads work” by Tim Ambler in International Journal of Advertising.

Instead of posting a text about the competing theories in this first column of mine and thus oversimplifying it for you my dear colleagues – I’d rather invite you all to get your hands on that brilliant article, read all of it and discuss it with your colleagues, consultants and clients.

As a best-case scenario we will all help develop that knowledge platform a bit more and make it both deeper and wider. And we’d do it by joining forces and pooling our knowledge and push our profession forward.

I am looking forward to coming back with new notes on good theories, knowledge platforms and how we should all be on the lookout for nonsense – regardless of how beautifully wrapped it might appear.

Cheers!

Tags: I&F McCann GroupMcCannMcCann Sweden
ShareTweetShare

Related Posts

Diary of a Methuselah #93: The Book Hotel Yugoslavia has started living its life
Diary

Diary of a Methuselah #139: Vera Lloyd-Thomas, Jelena Ristić, Vlatko Dimovski, Marija Vićić…

16/01/2019
IPG Mediabrands SEE agencies among the leaders in Serbia, Croatia and Bulgaria
News

IPG Mediabrands SEE agencies among the leaders in Serbia, Croatia and Bulgaria

24/07/2018
Interview

Marija Vićić: You can’t communicate others well if you don’t communicate the company you work for clearly, efficiently and credibly

15/05/2018
Calle Hägg new MD at McCann Oslo
News

Calle Hägg new MD at McCann Oslo

14/05/2018
UM Skopje at expert training in Facebook's Dublin HQ 2
News

UM Skopje at expert training in Facebook’s Dublin HQ

09/05/2018
Gold for “Rockets and Rebels”, the brand strategy book by SDG
News

Gold for “Rockets and Rebels”, the brand strategy book by SDG

08/05/2018
Next Post
Vedran Vereš: Brands that want to be leaders must be relevant within the culture in which they operate, as advertising is becoming easier to avoid

Vedran Vereš: Brands that want to be leaders must be relevant within the culture in which they operate, as advertising is becoming easier to avoid

Press Clipping Slovenia

SOF 30

Kreativni portfolio 04 Knjiga

Konferencija o kreativnosti

Mercator Dobrodelna Galerija

Konzum

McCann I&F Grupa Report

Apriori World

Media-Marketing.com

2011-2020 © All rights reserved.

Portal Media-Marketing.com

  • About us
  • Marketing
  • Impressum
  • Contact
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Privacy Policy

Social Media

  • News
  • Topic of the day
  • Interview
  • Opinion
  • Diary
  • Young Leaders
  • Three questions
  • Media Marketing
    • About us
    • Marketing
    • Impressum
    • Contact
    • Terms and Conditions
    • Privacy Policy
  • Advanced search
  • en English
  • bs Bosnian

2011-2020 © All rights reserved.

Prihvatanjem kolačića se slažete s našim Uslovima korištenja i Politikom privatnosti.PRIHVATAM